On Ethnographic Allegory
PDF (Русский)

Keywords

ethnography
textualization
allegory
pastoral
interpretation of cultures
writing

How to Cite

КлиффордД., КирчикО., & КорбутА. (2014). On Ethnographic Allegory. Russian Sociological Review, 13(3), 94-125. Retrieved from https://ojs.hse.ru/index.php/sociologica/article/view/107

Abstract

In now classic article, James Clifford offers a novel perspective on ethnographic texts. Inspired by literary studies (e.g. Jacques Derrida’s grammatology) he uses contemporary ethnographic works to question ethnography’s claims of scientific objectivity and a clear distinction between allegorical and factual. If ethnography aims to keep its contemporary relevance, it should specifically focus on allegory as an intrinsic quality of ethnographic texts This kind of analysis may assume that any ethnographic text accounts for facts and events but at the same time it tackles the moral, ideological or even cosmological issues. According to Clifford, ethnography has been dominated by a “pastoral” allegorical register which allowed an ethnographer to occupy a privileged position to interpret other, non-writing cultures. Clifford notices that this register is loosing support in the modern world since the difference between illiterate and literate cultures is not relevant anymore. Ethnographic pastoral is now replaced with self-reflexive and dialogical forms of ethnographic writing, analyzed by Clifford by the example of Marjorie Shostak’s book  Nisa: The Life and Words of a !Kung Woman.
PDF (Русский)

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.